Defensive stability is so important to any team looking to mount a challenge in the NHL, and David Alter likes what he sees in Toronto.
The Toronto Maple Leafs have struggled over the last few seasons with inconsistency between the pipes, a challenge that has often undermined their aspirations for a deep postseason run. However, they seem to have ushered in a new era of stability, largely attributed to the acquisition of goaltender Anthony Stolarz. His arrival has not only fortified the team’s defensive backbone but also instilled a renewed sense of confidence among players and fans alike.
The Maple Leafs signed Stolarz to a two-year, $5 million contract on July 1. Stolarz, fresh off a Stanley Cup victory with the Florida Panthers, recognized the opportunity in Toronto to potentially secure a starting role. Joseph Woll had firmly established himself as the incumbent in net, particularly with the way he helped during the 2024 first-round playoff series against the Boston Bruins. Down 3-1 in the best-of-seven series, Woll came in for Games 5 and 6 and helped the Leafs force a deciding Game 7. The only problem was Woll was injured at the end of Game 6, forcing Ilya Samsonov (now with the Vegas Golden Knights) to start Game 7.
The early stages this season tested the Maple Leafs’ goaltending depth. Woll expected to start during the team’s opening game on Oct. 9 against the Montreal Canadiens, was sidelined with groin tightness, thrusting Stolarz into a pivotal role. Demonstrating resilience and poise, Stolarz shouldered the increased workload as Woll was unavailable for two weeks, delivering performances that not only kept the team competitive but also highlighted his capability as a reliable starter.
One notable performance was on November 5, 2024, when Stolarz earned his first shutout with the Maple Leafs in a 4-0 victory over the Bruins. He turned aside all 29 shots faced, showcasing his composure under pressure. Stolarz acknowledged the support from the fans, stating, “It’s always going to get you going, and you appreciate the support and they’re the ones who kind of drive us and give us energy.” It was a big win against a divisional rival that seems to always get the better of Toronto.
Stolarz’s impact has been felt by his teammates, especially in a season where the club completely overhaul their defense. Morgan Rielly expressed confidence in the new goaltender saying “I’m really comfortable with him back there.” That’s good praise coming from a defense that has been overhauled with the additions of Chris Tanev and Oliver Ekman-Larsson.
Forward Mitch Marner also praised Stolarz’s contributions, highlighting his work ethic and positive influence in the locker room. “He’s been a rock for us,” Marner commented. “His dedication and approach to the game have been inspiring, and it’s great to see him getting the results he deserves.”
Stolarz’s performance metrics underscore his value to the team. He entered the day of November 18th tie for the NHL lead in save percentage among netminders who have seven starts or more at .927.
It’s been a long time since the Maple Leafs had a goaltender they can rely on and Stolarz appears to be that guy. Especially as of this writing when the Leafs only have six even strength goals scored in their last six games. If he keeps this up, it won’t be long before we start talking about him as a potential candidate. As soon as the Bodog NHL futures open up on trophies, he might be a nice value bet.
But of course the question is, and will always be until April, if he is as good in the Stanley Cup Playoffs? He is a Stanley Cup Champion, but he’s only played in one playoff game, coming on in relief of Sergei Bobrovsky in Game 4 of the Final. Time will tell. But for now, it’s hasn’t felt so calm in the Leafs net for a long time.